Skip to content
Foodatron logoFoodatron
Plate
Leader
Thin Mints3
VS
All Butter Scottish Shortbread Fingers2

Thin Mints leads 3–2 · 5 categories decided

Each value is per 100 g edible portion.

The verdict

Thin Mints comes out ahead, winning 3 of 5 nutrient match-ups.

Pick Thin Mints for less sugar, less saturated fat and less sodium.

Pick All Butter Scottish Shortbread Fingers for more protein and more fiber.

Equal weight (per 100 g)Common servingEqual calories

Head-to-head

  • Energy
    516.13 kcal
    517 kcal
  • Proteinmore is better
    2 g
    5.5 gWIN
  • Carbohydrate
    21 g
    59.3 g
  • Fibermore is better
    1 g
    2.8 gWIN
  • Total sugarsless is better
    WIN10 g
    17 g
  • Total fat
    7 g
    28 g
  • Saturated fatless is better
    WIN5 g
    17.5 g
  • Sodiumless is better
    WIN120 mg
    280 mg
  • Potassiummore is better
    —
    —
  • Calciummore is better
    10 mg
    —
  • Ironmore is better
    1.94 mg
    —
  • Magnesiummore is better
    —
    —
  • Vitamin Cmore is better
    —
    —
  • Vitamin Dmore is better
    —
    —

Winners are decided by deterministic per-metric rules on the stated basis; ties and missing data don’t score (missing ≠ zero). Educational information only — not medical advice.

Thin Mints vs All Butter Scottish Shortbread Fingers · Foodatron